Skip to content

Forces entered by hand

Check a member with no analysis or no model, or type over what the analysis gave, and what the row, sheet and report say about it.

Design checks 6 min read

A strength check can verify forces you type. Use it to check a member from someone else's calculation with nothing modelled, to try a member before the model exists, or to override one member whose analysis you don't trust. The forces go through the same module and the same clauses as forces from a solve. The check adds no load factor, second-order effect or imperfection: the forces are the design forces you state.

Entering forces is part of every design check, on every plan. Such a check counts towards the plan's design checks per project like any other.

Checking a member with no analysis

  1. Start a strength check. New check in the design checks dialog, and pick a module.
  2. Set the source. On the Setup tab, under Which forces, set Source to Entered by hand. The analysis, combination and member rows give way to one row, Members and forces entered by hand. Open it.
  3. Add a member. Add member offers New member, a name, section, material and length that the check owns and nothing in the model has, or From the model, a member of the model with your forces in place of the analysis. A model isn't needed for the first.
  4. Type the forces. A new member has one hand combination, named HC1, with rows at 0, L/2 and L. Type over any cell. Hand combination adds another and Position adds a row.
  5. Apply. Changes to a check wait for Apply, as elsewhere in the dialog.

The sheet holds two tables, each whole. The members table lists Member, Section, Material, length and Cantilever, with a × always in view. A member missing a section or material reads Not verified: no section. Pick one. A model member that was deleted reads No longer in the model, so it reads not verified.

The forces table has a Member column and Hand combination, then , , , , , and in the project's units. A value can also be typed with its own unit. is positive in tension and negative in compression. The combination's name is yours. It holds the design forces of that combination, already factored, and isn't one of the project's load combinations.

Settings per member on the Setup tab lists standalone members too. Set , , , Load at and the rest of the module's per-member fields there. A standalone member has no framing and no restraints, so Effective lengths is not offered on a check on typed forces: is 1 unless you state it, or 2 at a free end. Cantilever holds a standalone member at its start and leaves its end free. Off, it has forks at both ends.

Positions along the member

A row is a position along the member with the forces at it.

What you typeWhat the check reads
One rowConstant along the whole member
Past the last rowThat row's values hold
An empty cell between two rowsRead from its neighbours, shown grey
An empty cell at or 0
Two rows at one A jump, as under a point load or a point moment. A third at that is refused

runs from 0 to L and is kept as a fraction of L, so the positions scale if the length changes.

Between positions:

ColumnHow it runs
, , , Straight
, Straight through two values, a parabola through three, and a monotone curve through more that never passes a typed value

So of 0, 150 and 0 kNm at 0, L/2 and L reads as the parabola of a uniform load, with its peak at mid-span, and finds that row of the table. For the triangle of a midspan point load, type two rows at L/2 with the same and the shear changing sign between them. Each stretch then runs straight.

Keyboard and paste

Ctrl+D fills down, and Delete removes a selected member or position. Paste from a spreadsheet in the order , , , , , , . Pasting onto a member adds a new combination, or with a combination's name in the first column it fills that one, and a blank name goes on with the one above. A cell that isn't a valid value is left as it was and the sheet says how many.

Typing over one member's forces

In a check on an analysis, open a member's row and press Enter forces by hand. This starts a hand combination named HC1 from what the analysis gave under the governing combination, and takes you to the forces table. From then on that member is verified under its typed combinations alone, not the check's. Every other member stays on the analysis.

The opened row offers Edit the forces, and Back to the analysis, which removes the typed forces and returns the member to the check's combinations. Both wait for Apply.

What is read that you didn't type

A row on typed forces has nothing behind it but those forces, so the check says what it assumes in its notes:

  • Load position. Unless you state one, reads the load on the destabilising side, whichever sign the moment has, so the same beam doesn't pass or fail on how someone wrote it. State Load at if it sits elsewhere. See Where the load sits.
  • Ends. A standalone member in bending reads forks at both ends. Mark it a cantilever if it is one.
  • Shear. A moment that varies along the member with no shear typed reads shear as zero and says so. Type to check it.

A hand combination with nothing typed in it reads not verified, not a passing number.

What the row, sheet and report say

A result on typed forces says so everywhere it appears:

WhereWhat it says
Results tableA pencil beside the combination; opened, Forces entered by hand, not from an analysis.
Checks table in the dockEntered by hand in the Permutation column
Calculation sheetA warning block, Forces entered by hand, with that sentence, and no analysis named
ReportThe same warning on the check, with the members it applies to listed

The report does not say where the forces came from, so state that yourself. A reviewer can't trace a typed number to a load case.

How it behaves on a change

  • Solving doesn't touch typed forces, and they don't go out of date when the analysis does. A model member's section or length change still reruns the check.
  • The lightest-section offer works on typed forces. On a standalone member, applying it changes the section the check owns and nothing solves. On a model member it changes the model and re-solves as usual, and the typed forces stay as typed.
  • Deflection, drift and frequency read displacements, so they stay on an analysis. Source is unavailable on those checks, and Enter forces by hand isn't offered.

Design checks for the dialog and how a result reads; Steel — EN 1993-1-1, Stainless steel and Steel — AISC 360 for what each module verifies.

Something wrong or unclear on this page? Tell us, and it gets corrected.